Friday, October 13, 2006

Movements

I first want to take a moment to recommend that you visit the Order of Saint Stephen blog. Not only do I recommend the practices they are talking about and valuing, but I recommend the idea of an "order" all together. These are some great people who are "doing it" and have been.

There has been something popping up in their comments though that I want to touch on in this post. When there was not an immediate update on the site to some of what they were planning people got pessimistic... and fast. Pessimism is certainly not new or suprising. Pessimism on the web is even less suprising. But what I want to address is this idea of movements.

In the past (yes, I'll leave it as the ambigious all of history) there has been this sense that the only thing worth starting is something that's will somehow live on forever. The "success" of something was dependent on its "formality" in organization, control and measurable features. If an organization or movement was successful it was growing in measurable ways. If it wasn't growing, then it was failing and the worse failure is the disappearance of the measurable and controlable things.

In this postmodern world, movements are embraced, not because of the ways they can be measured or controlled, but because of what they begin (both seen and unseen). This may seem a bit of language manipulation, but let me use an example from real life.

There was a church community, let's call it "the Fish-house", that was started as a ministry to young families in an urban environment. As it began, it attracted some young couples who came together, some came to proclaim faith in Christ, some grew in their faith and their community grew in numbers and in intimacy. Then, almost as quickly as it had begun, the momentum of new families attending ceased. There seemed to be a ceiling on the size of the community. In the midst of this stunted growth in one area, there was growth in another. The community of young couples and families grew closer and closer together and in faith. It was only a matter of two years before almost every one of the families felt called to ministry... but in other cities. The Fish-house was birthed, grew and died in just over two years.

It was considered a failure by those who aimed to fund it. It didn't make it. It never realized its potential. "It had such promise," they sadly muttered.

Here is where I would challenge this idea that movements must last forever [or at least as long as I'm interested :-)]. The reality of the Fish-house is that it may not have lasted as an organization in a formal sense, but the movement of that community continues to this day. The families that were a part of that community are now all over the globe doing and leading ministry. It was not to be a physical institution that would last, but it has proven to be a movement of the Spirit.

All of those words and that true story, to say this... movements are beautiful because of what they begin in us. They open doors in seen and unseen ways to those places that might have been a mystery to us before... or perhaps to re-discover something that has been tucked away in the shadows of our experience. The point of great movements, like great questions, is that they would open doors in our minds, hearts and experiences that we may never have opened ourselves.

Perhaps the greatest form of hospitality is the opening of doors for one another and the courage to walk through the doors opened for us.

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, the German author said it well, "Whatever you can do or dream you can, begin it. Boldness has genius, power and magic in it. Begin it now."

2 comments:

Josh Kleinfeld said...

i take movements quite often.

Brian said...

Great points Erik!

I agree that we are as a Holiness church called to a different way of life. In fact I'd like to say that we are all called to this kind of life as a Christian (and our Nazarene denomination emphasizes that). I also know that we as Nazarenes were founded to minister and reach out to those who are marginalized.

I find great hope in our story! However, I do think that in all movements and organizations (especially those who are 100 years old) there are times when we need to RE:call the story that has defined us and RE:imagine a future in keeping with that tradition.

Are we as Nazarene's supposed to be doing this kind of ministry already? Sure. But what I think the order of St. Stephen (and other modern day orders) is trying to do is call people to a rhythm of life that embraces this in all aspects. Too often, I would argue, we have done "compassionate ministry" a few times a year and thought well of ourselves, or paid our tithes and been happy that we have done our duty. I do not believe that to be enough.

As someone who has grown up Catholic, you probably have a better understanding of a lifestyle spent serving others. There is something we need to learn from this way of life.

I agree with you that our culture is extremely consumer oriented. And I would also argue that most of our ministries in church feed into this - seeking to help meet people's needs. If we are truly after the heart of Christ we must rediscover that this was not what Christ did - he called people into the "best kind of life" which was a life loving God and loving neighbor.

I think that's as clear as mud.